CALL US 0207 2929 140

Menu
Personal Trainer Blogs

PERSONAL TRAINER & FITNESS BLOGS

Banner Iamage Jeremy Boyd
4 MIN READ

Why The Science For The Paleo Doesn't Matter

Written By

Jeremy Boyd

Category

Nutrition, Personal Training

Posted On

21 November 2013

Share Article

Over the last 10 years, the Paleo and Primal diets have steadily risen in popularity. Unfortunately, alongside this increase in practice, there has also been a great deal of criticism of the 'supposed' science surrounding the claims of these approaches.

It is important to note that, like most commercial nutrition solutions (a.k.a. diets), the premise has to be sold. It is rarely enough to tell people that an approach is beneficial, rather they need to be convinced of why. For that reason, the claimed origins of almost any diet should be taken with a pinch of salt, as they may have more than a little marketing spin in their heritage.

That said, the broad claims of the paleo or primal propositions are as follows:

  • Our ancestors were generally healthier than we are
  • Our ancestors ate healthier than we do

And that's it. Other than the above assertions, none of the primal diets claim anything specifically, although many practitioners of the diet will claim it prevents various health issues and diseases. The diets and their authors themselves however, claim very little.

Assessing the two main claims of the diets reveals the following:

Our lifestyles are nothing alike - Trying to compare modern life to that our ancestors experienced thousands of years ago is not only unrealistic, but also irrelevant.

Our ancestors had an average lifespan of 30 years, nowhere near long enough to develop the chronic diseases that are prevalent in todays society.

Environmental contaminants, toxins and pollutants were almost non-existent. Therefore our immune systems will develop very differently because of the greater number of stimuli that the body must respond and adapt to.

The prevalence of predators is almost non-existent today. Wild animals would represent potential threats to our Palaeolithic ancestors, resulting in a different state of physical readiness and preparedness and therefore potentially, energy demands.

Our ancestors would have been exposed to fewer creature comforts, thereby encouraging a hardiness or resilience that is typically rarer in todays society. The modern reliance on central heating, hot showers and wall cavity insulation, will almost certainly have resulted in certain physiological adaptations or even regressions.

Our food availability is nothing alike One of the most common criticisms of the paleo and primal propositions, is that modern foods simply did not exist in anything like their current forms that far back in time.

One of the greatest areas in which expert opinion converges, is that we function better and with fewer health issues when consumed a diet low in unrefined foods. The argument being that natural or wholefoods are more suited to our digestive and endocrine systems. However, when viewed in more detail, most common vegetables have been bred to provide greater palatability, digestibility and availability. Therefore, even the most unrefined of foods bears little resemblance to that available to our ancestors.

But the truth is: None of this matters.

When assessing any diet, nutritional practice or lifestyle change, there are really only a few questions that need to be answered:

  • Does it provide a healthy macronutrient balance?
  • Does it provide a broad spectrum of nutrients?
  • Does it promote healthy body composition?
  • Does it fit with the participant's lifestyle?
  • Is it sustainable in the long term?

If the answer to the above questions is yes, then the specific spin a particular diet is given has little bearing on whether it should be followed or not. In the case of the paleo/primal diets, we can determine the following:

  1. Ancestral diets place a high value on lean meats/fish and wholefood vegetable sources. These food groups are by large, lower in carbohydrates and higher in proteins and fats, a macronutrient ratio largely accepted to be healthy for the average person. Obviously, there are some populations whose needs may not be specifically or even optimally met by a complete adherence to an ancestral approach, but then the question here relates to the broad strokes of the approach, not the minutiae.
  2. The recommended intake of vegetables, fruits and wild meats/fish, means that most essential and beneficial nutrients will be plentiful.
  3. The typical macronutrient ratios will generally reduce drastic fluctuations in blood sugar levels, promote optimal tissue repair and limit or prevent inflammation. All three of these outcomes help promote a lean physique, which often correlates with improved markers of health and lowered risk of disease.
  4. This one is entirely individual and can only be answered by each participant. Largely though, most proponents of the ancestral eating approach find it to be practical and realistic, although it may take some experimenting initially to find the best practices on a personal level.
  5. One of the greatest challenges faced by most dieters is the ability to sustain the changes required by a diet in the long term and therefore maintain their results. Like any diet that is drastically different to an individuals current lifestyle, ancestral eating should be adopted gradually, ideally one component at a time. Those who completely overhaul their nutritional habits at the outset may experience greater challenges in the long run, although there are certainly those who have adopted the practices with little difficulty.

So overall, even though the published claims about the scientific validity of the approach are interesting, they are hardly conclusive or even definitive. Despite that, the approach itself has a number of benefits for those who are able to follow it. Just don't get caught up in the marketing spiel or spin that proponents invariably use to make it appealing or exciting.


blog comments powered by Disqus



  • Written By

    Bryn Ray

    Category

    General Fitness

    Posted On

    5 August 2016

    “Feeling” is one of the most important components of training for physique. No matter what gym you go to, you will have seen someone doing a bicep curl, for example, with little regard for proper technique or knowledge of what they are doing. They are just trying to heave as much weight as possible, shouting and screaming, and paying little or no attention to the exercise. Success in body-building however comes from the muscular contraction. It is both the key and the secret. If you don’t FEEL the muscle, you can’t grow the muscle.

  • Written By

    Jeremy Boyd

    Category

    Business and Marketing, Life Coaching, Personal Training

    Posted On

    20 January 2016

    The greatest challenge in achieving this, is that there is no ‘best’ session, nor is there any way to determine if there ever was. That said, there are better and worse ways of designing programmes.

  • Written By

    Jeremy Boyd

    Category

    Life Coaching, Personal Training

    Posted On

    15 December 2014

    Neuro Linguistic Programming is essentially the science of communication via the spoken word. Since the original works of Bandler and Grinder in the 1970’s, more and more people are studying it. But why? What makes the study of language so appealing and valuable?

  • Written By

    Hazel Goudie

    Category

    The Limbic System

    Posted On

    20 January 2014

    The limbic system, also called the paleomammalian brain, is a complex collection of brain structures that lie on both sides of the thalamus, directly under the cerebrum. It is thought by some neuroscientists that it was added to the forebrain in the course of evolution. The main limbic structures include the hippocampus (memory centre), the amygdala (anger, anxiety and stress centre) and the limbic cortex that interconnects with the prefrontal cortex, which is responsible for reasoning and judgment. The limbic system supports functions such as emotion, behaviour and motivation and is devoted to supporting our survival structures that protect and regulate human emotions. Research suggests that it appears to be primarily responsible for emotional life, and it has a great deal to do with the formation of memories. This information suggests that emotional wellbeing and happiness is linked to the wellbeing of the limbic system. Therefore it is possible that a deterioration of the limbic system could lead to more negative, out of control emotions such as rage and depression, leading to violence and a general neurological decline.

  • Written By

    TRAINFITNESS Support

    Category

    Nutrition

    Posted On

    10 August 2016

    There is a lot of buzz around the benefits of smoothies, but just why are they so good? In the post below we’ve outlined three key benefits of smoothies and we’ve also written a FREE smoothie recipe ebook which you can find here:

  • Written By

    Michael Betts

    Category

    General Fitness

    Posted On

    19 July 2016

    Changing careers can be both exciting and scary. The prospect of having a new job as a personal trainer, where you are your own boss, can be a very motivating. The idea of having to start studying again; however, may feel like a huge hurdle. The longer it has been since you last studied, the higher that hurdle may seem.